
Early History of the Brevard-Davidson River Presbyterian Church
By Gene Baker
The history of the Brevard-Davidson River Presbyterian Church began shortly after the first permanent settlers arrived in the area we now call Transylvania County. James Davidson, Benjamin Davidson, and Samuel Davis played significant roles in the development of the church prior to the official organization of the Davidson River Presbyterian Church in 1828. The Davidsons had settled on Ben Davidson’s Creek, now Davidson River. Davis is believed to have been the son of John Davis, who appears to have settled on Simon Dunn’s Creek, now Dunn’s Creek.
The first indication that there was a Presbyterian church in the area was in 1794, when the Presbytery of Abington listed three churches within the Blue Ridge. These were Rim’s (Reems) Creek, Head of Swanano (Swannanoa) and Head of F. (French) Broad.
These churches became part of Concord Presbytery in 1795. Its list of churches in 1796 included Great Plain of the French Broad, led by Samuel Davis as a licentiate for the ministry. The first clue as to where this church was located was found in a 1797 deed that stated that there was a “presbyterian Meeting House on the east side of the French Broad River and just under the Indian Mountain,” now known as Dunn’s Rock. Confirming this is the wording in a request for a grant of land entered in 1800 which said “…about one hundred poles below the presbyterian Meeting House…crossing Dunn’s Creek…” Another deed from that time states “…including the place known as Sam Davises Meeting…called the presbyterian Meeting house below the mouth of Dunn’s Creek…”
(Figure 1) – The top writing is difficult to make out but it says:
“French Broad Valley, from Dunns’ Rock, Beautiful Sapphire Country, Brevard, N.C.”
The assumption is made that Davis changed the name of the church to Great Plain of the French Broad, but what led him to that? Perhaps a clue can be seen in the 1925 postcard shown in Figure 1, which shows a view of the French Broad River valley from the top of Dunn’s Rock. Having that view, it seems reasonable that the name would come to mind.
There are two other features shown in the postcard that are of significance. A barn is visible at the bottom center. All of the information available on the Meeting House – Mamre Church indicates that is where it was located, as discussed below. Also visible at the bottom center is the historic Dunn’s Rock Bridge.
The old Concord Presbytery ordained and installed Samuel Davis as “pastor of the Mamre congregation” on March 28, 1798. Davis was already in the area serving the Great Plain of the French Broad church. It would appear that Davis changed the name of the church, but where did the name “Mamre” come from? The answer is likely found in Genesis. Genesis 18:1 states “And the Lord appeared unto him in the Plains of Mamre.” The view of the French Broad River valley as seen from the top of Dunn’s Rock is likely what precipitated both names for this church.
A proposed location of the Mamre Church, in the area now known as Dunn’s Rock, was made using numerous old deeds and land grants that made mention of the “Presbyterian Meeting House” and “Sam Davises Meeting.” The primary document used was a deed to Zachariah Candler recorded as NC Land Grant #1028 on April 3, 1804 (Buncombe County Deed Book 8; Pages 11, 12). The original request for this land was made on August 15, 1800 (Secretary of State Record Books; Volume 116, Page 120). A plat for that land grant is shown in Figure 2. The location chosen for the Mamre Church was on a little knoll above the French Broad River on US 276E, across from the entrance to Rockbrook Camp, on the right just before the sharp curve of the highway. The church was likely founded in this area because the Davis’ had settled there early on, were strong Presbyterians and Samuel was studying for the ministry. The location of the Mamre Presbyterian Meeting House is shown in Julie Singdahlsen’s watercolor/collage shown in Figure 3. It is on display in the Davidson River History Room of the B-DRPC.
The last reference to the Mamre Church as an active congregation was this in 1798; it continued to be listed in presbytery records until 1829, but vacant. All records indicate that, by 1800, the church had moved down river to “Ben Davidson’s Creek,” Davidson River. Samuel Davis had married Benjamin Davidson’s daughter Rhodia. James Davidson was an elder in the Mamre Church. Benjamin Davidson had likely been an active member also, as further mention of the church indicates that the congregation was meeting in his home. It appears at this point that it became the Davidson River Church, the reaon for the move remains unclear.
Bishop Francis Asbury wrote in his “Journals” on November 10, 1800 (Volume 2, Chapter 1, page 263) that “We…made upwards through the barrens of Broad to Davidson’s, whose name names the stream. The aged mother and daughters insited upon giving notice for a meeting: in consequence thereof Mr. Davis, the Presbyerian minister, and several others came together.”
Sessional records in Minute Book (1941-1949) staes on the first page: “Davidson River Church organized summer of 1800 with three Camp Meeting Grounds: Davidson River, Mills River, and Cane Creek, Rev. Samuel Davis, Pastor.”
The obituary of Captain John Murray, which appeared in the Asheville News, April 12, 1860, gives some further clues about the church during this time. He joined the Presbyterian Church at Davidson River near the close of 1802 and was married in May 1803 to Elizabeth Davidson, daughter of Benjamin Davidson.
The church at Davidson River becoming extinct, he lived twenty yars destitute of church privileges.
At the reorganization of the church at Davidson River, by Reverend Christopher Bradshaw, he was chosen one of the leaders.
As just indicated by becoming extinct, nothing more is known about the church until it was organized or reorganized by Concord Presbytery in Juen of 1828, when the Davidson River Presbyterian Church was formed at the request of the Reverend Christopher Bradshaw and three Ruling Elders, viz: John Murray, G.D. Davis, and Ethan Davis. The church started with 28 charter members and grew to 40 members by the end of the year. A church was constructed across the river from Benjamin Davidson’s home in an area known as Walnut Grove. The land had been deeded by Davidson “unto the said John Mackey, John Clayton, George O. Neil, G.D. Davis and William Orr the trustees that was appointed for the building of the Free Meeting House” in December of 1826. It is thought that this area was being used, and had been for some time, as a Meeting Ground shared by Presbyterians, Methodists, and Baptists.
The rest of the history of the Brevard-Davidson River Presbyterian Church can be found in “History of the Brevard-Davidson River Presbyterian Church 1798 – 2000” by the Reverend Ben Ormand. This was also the source of some of the information contained herein. The Brevard Presbyterian Church as organized in October, 1891. The two churches were united in February, 1931.
Correction to Ben’s book: the top line on page three should read “Johnson’s called the Presbyterian Meeting House below the mouth of Dunn’s Creek.”

